Chemical Forums
Chemistry Forums for Students => Organic Chemistry Forum => Topic started by: jkulier on July 20, 2009, 10:47:57 PM
-
Hi there,
in order to determine the type of reaction that occurs, I have to figure out whether or not mixing H2O and CH3CN would produce a good or poor nucleophile.
I have considered H2O giving up a proton to CH3CN, but that would not make much sense because there is no place for the proton to attach to. The other option is for CH3CN to lose a proton to water, but the same problem arises.
Any guidance would be great, because I am very lost.
Thanks in advance :)
-
I think that the nitrile carbon will undergo attack by water to give an sp2-hybridised intermediate imine anion. Someone please correct me if I'm wrong ::).
------
By the way, isn't the product ethanoic acid?
-
H2O doesn't react with MeCN at all, so neither a good nor a poor new nucleophile would be obtained by mixing the two materials.
the O of H2O is not nucleophilic enough to attack the C of MeCN unless the MeCN's N atom is protonated by which the electrophilicity of the MeCN is enhanced.
-
I don't think the answer is found in the interaction of the two solvents. I think you should determine what effect pure acetonitrile and water has on the reaction. Acetonitrile is a classic dipolar aprotic solvent and improves nucleophilicity in some reactions. Water also effects a reaction. I think the answer is to compare whether a nucleophile is enhanced in acetonitrile or water and what effect water will on the overall reaction.
By the wording of the question ("type of reaction"), it would appear that a broader answer than nucleophilicity might be being sought.