If I understand you, the standard R2 is fine, but your sample RSD is 50%? I suppose it depends on to what standard your analytical results are help by any of a variety of judgement boards but ... yes, no matter what the analytical method, and RSD of 50% is just awful. I know, I've gotten them myself on an HPLC run, and you just have to disappoint people with the grim reality that you don't have an answer for them, and you do have to start over.
Now, retuning to ICP, there can certainly be matrix effects with the analytical samples that are distinct from standards. Or this could be a sample handling error. Or a sudden drift in the instrument. But you really haven't given us enough details to figure this out.