I would look at this plate and say that your chromatography (separation of two major components) is actually better than your original plate, where the two spots are barely resolved.
I think that your treatment of these "bad" plates has resulted in the uptake of some water vapour from the atmosphere when you let them cool from 100 deg. C in the open; after heating, they should have been immediately placed in a desiccator over blue silica gel and allowed to cool, if you wanted very active plates.
If this was my project, I would run the plates with MeOH/CH2Cl2 right to top of plate to clean them; then remove plates and allow to air-dry in the open; maybe use hair dryer on warm setting to blow off the organic solvents (IN A HOOD) to give an opaque white surface; now store the plates overnight in a closed vessel that has a beaker of water inside. This will give a saturated water atmosphere, and each plate will absorb the same amount of H2O----you will have de-activated the plates and may be able to consistently generate a spot pattern similar to the "bad" plate.