Sanity check: molar mass of oxygen is higher, so it should effuse slower, yet your result suggest more oxygen effused. Something is apparently wrong.
Graham's law is
[tex]\frac {Rate~of~effusion~of~gas_1}{Rate~of~effusion~of~gas_2} = \sqrt{\frac {M_2}{M_1}}[/tex]
It shouldn't matter which gas is which, as long as you are consistent.