So I think where I went wrong is immediately assuming since it was NBS that it had to be allylic bromination through a radical mechanism. But I started thinking (with a nudge from Dan) that NBS is just a constant, low concentration source of bromine. So I thought about it and after some google help, a article said the bromination of furan happens through a 1,4-addition type mechanism. Attached is the second half of the mechanis, then the bromination mechanism.
Does this seem more logical? Does to me.
Thanks Dan