If you'd like some confirmation, then I'd say you have it correct. Sometimes, it's hard to trust your own instincts. But when you're in a situation like this, it's important to ask the other person, the criteria they're using for their point of view. They may have nothing to say except, "Heard it online somewhere," or "Teacher says so," or "We're done with that, and we're moving on, " or some such foo. At least you know what sort of person you're dealing with, in that situation.