I agree with all of jdurg's comments, so I'll add some props for some others:
Neon - Lovely color in gas discharge tubes. Neon was first discovered by its spectra (like many elements, thallium included), so the first sign anybody had of this new element was the sight of that intense red-orange glow. I think it is cool to imagine that discovery.
Iodine - Fairly cool looking crystals, and very pretty violet vapor. Besides, its by far the easiest halogen to handle.
Mercury - Pretty obvious, too bad it is so dangerous.
Iron - Ferromagnetism is a neat property (although Fe is not alone), forms lots of colored complexes so it is fun to experiment with, tremendously economically important, plus we need it to breathe. (Another one of those colored complexes.)
Copper - I think this might be the prettiest metal, plus it has some of the prettiest minerals (e.g. malachite and azurite).
Plutonium - Many brightly colored solutions (with different complexes and oxidation states), bizzare mechanical properties (density changes of 30% or so, strange electrical and thermal conductivity, many different crystal structures, solid Pu floats on liquid unlike almost everything else.) It holds a huge amount of energy, hence its dark side, which is already responsible for 100,000 or so deaths
Happily and sadly, I can't seem to get a real sample. The North Koreans won't answer my emails.
Cesium - jdurg already mentioned this, but liquid Cs is just so cool, I'll mention it again.