Thanks Arkcon.
I've done a bit more reading into it and I think the peak may be coming out of alpha-angelica lactone.
To my understanding, a lot of commercial GVL is synthesized by catalytic hydrogenation of levulinic acid. Incomplete hydrogenation (or high synthesis temperature) will result in alpha-angelica lactone residue being present.
While this is the most likely possibility, the peak positions do not seem to match.
Carbonyl peak for alpha-angelica lactone had been reported at 1809 cm-1 (Jones, 1959) though the Spectral Database of Organic Compound (sdbs.db.aist.go.jp) reported peak at 1798 cm-1. The peak I observed in my run is somewhat higher at 1820 cm-1.
Jones, R.N., et al., Canadian Journal of Chemistry, The carbonyl stretching bands in the infrared spectra of unsaturated lactones, 37, pp. 2007-2022.