This is a complicated question, made all the worse by your scope -- you have a novice performing your organic synthesis?
OK, so, you have SOP's I have to assume, governing NMR and IR spec of your organic raw materials, and you've written acceptance characteristics. Now you need something for the inorganic reagents.
For Cu(I), you've got an easy answer you've already mentioned, reduced Cu(I) is white or brown (I can't remember) and oxidized, or spent or degraded Cu(II) is blue. There's a reason why we use any inorganic reagent, but you'll have to come up with a simple reaction that tells you its fitness. Something colurmetric for each reagent that you can quickly read in the UV-Vis spec (assuming you have one.)
You can start by listing them all, and what reaction they're meant to perform.
Meantime, you can just say, "Must be freshly prepared" Then, save some, and evaluate portions over time, to establish storage times.